Picture this: one of your star counselors, the one who’s been with you through thick and thin, suddenly announces they’re leaving. Not just leaving—starting their own agency. It’s like watching your favorite player join the rival team. Painful, right? But before you spiral into worry, let’s take a step back and unpack this.
Let’s be real—the fear of losing your talent to competition is valid. Counselors are the backbone of your agency. They build relationships with students, provide guidance, and often become the face of your brand. So, the idea of them taking those relationships and striking out on their own? It’s unnerving.
But here’s the thing: this fear isn’t unique to education agents. Every industry faces it. From tech startups worried about developers launching competing apps to law firms anxious about associates taking clients, it’s a universal concern. The question isn’t if this could happen—it’s how you handle it.
Ambition Meets Opportunity Some counselors are natural entrepreneurs. They see the potential to build something of their own and take the leap. It’s not personal; it’s just the pull of ambition.
Perceived Gaps in the Current Setup Maybe they’ve noticed inefficiencies in how things are run. Or perhaps they feel they could offer a more tailored experience to students. When counselors spot gaps, it can spark ideas of doing things differently—and on their own terms.
Personal Recognition Imagine pouring your heart and soul into your work, only for the credit to go to someone else (or the company as a whole). Over time, this can leave even the most loyal team members wondering, “What if I built something where my name was on the door?”
The Temptation of Autonomy Freedom is a powerful motivator. The thought of setting their own hours, choosing their clients, and shaping their business—it’s enticing.
Here’s the honest answer: yes, but not excessively. Worrying is natural, but dwelling on it won’t stop it from happening. Instead, channel that energy into strategies that mitigate the risk and foster loyalty.
People stay where they feel valued. Simple, right? But building that kind of culture takes effort. Ask yourself:
Sometimes, it’s the little things—a heartfelt “thank you,” a public acknowledgment of their work, or a clear path for advancement—that make all the difference.
Let’s face it: no one wants to feel unheard. Create an environment where counselors can share their ideas, frustrations, and aspirations. By addressing concerns early, you might prevent them from becoming reasons to leave.
Do your counselors understand the long-term vision of your agency? If not, they might feel disconnected or uncertain about their future with you. Regularly communicate your goals and how they fit into the bigger picture. When people feel like they’re part of something meaningful, they’re less likely to walk away.
Let’s talk about the elephant in the room: even with all the right strategies, some counselors might still choose to leave. And that’s okay. Change is part of business. The key is to focus on what you can control.
Don’t let critical knowledge live in one person’s head. Create systems and processes to document key information, from client preferences to operational workflows. This way, even if someone leaves, the disruption is minimized.
Your agency’s reputation should never rest solely on the shoulders of one counselor. Invest in building a strong, recognizable brand that students and partners associate with quality and trust. When your brand stands out, it becomes harder for anyone to replicate your success.
When a counselor decides to leave, resist the urge to take it personally. Instead, handle the transition professionally. This not only preserves your reputation but also sets a positive example for your remaining team.
Here’s a mistake some agencies make: trying to hide the technology or processes they use, thinking it will prevent counselors from leaving or replicating their setup. The reality? This approach rarely works. Why? Because in today’s world, information is accessible. Whether it’s through online forums, networking events, or sheer curiosity, determined individuals can find what they’re looking for.
Instead of hiding your tools and processes, focus on showcasing how you use them better. For example, many agencies rely on CRMs to manage student data. The CRM itself isn’t a secret, but the way you customize it to enhance the student experience is your edge. Similarly, tools like automated invoice systems or integrations with platforms like Xero or QuickBooks are common in the industry. What sets you apart is how seamlessly these tools fit into your operations, saving time and improving outcomes.
By being transparent, you demonstrate confidence in your methods. It shows your counselors that success isn’t just about the tools but about the culture, expertise, and teamwork behind their use. This not only builds trust but also reduces the allure of starting from scratch elsewhere.
Here’s the truth many agents don’t want to admit: if counselors really want to open their own agency, they’ll likely find a way. Agreements with schools are relatively easy to secure, at least with the majority of institutions. The education industry thrives on collaboration, and schools are often open to new partnerships—especially with individuals who already have experience and connections.
What’s more, platforms like ApplyBoard have made the process even simpler. These tools offer streamlined solutions for working with schools, managing applications, and even providing training. For an ambitious counselor, the barriers to entry aren’t as high as they might seem.
This isn’t meant to alarm you but to emphasize the importance of focusing on what you can offer that others can’t. Your value lies not just in your network or systems but in the unique experience and culture you’ve built.
If you’re worried about competition, here’s a game-changing approach: create your own “blue ocean.” What does that mean? Instead of fighting over the same pool of opportunities as everyone else, focus on carving out a unique space where you stand alone.
Agencies that thrive are the ones that systematize their processes and make them scalable. They identify what sets them apart—whether it’s a niche market, a standout service, or an exceptional customer experience—and then they double down on it. Once you’ve defined your unique strategy, the next step is to make it reproducible. Why? Because consistency is key.
Measure everything. From application success rates to student satisfaction scores, data is your best friend. When you have measurable results, it’s easier to refine your approach, scale your business, and stay ahead of the competition. Think of it like a franchise model: every aspect of your operations should be so well-documented and efficient that anyone could replicate it—under your leadership, of course.
Let’s face it: losing a key counselor stings, but the impact can vary depending on your agency’s size.
For small agencies, losing a counselor can feel catastrophic. With fewer team members to share the workload, the departure of even one person can disrupt operations and strain remaining staff. Relationships with students might suffer, and rebuilding can take time. At this stage, cross-training your team and maintaining clear documentation of processes are vital to weathering such losses.
In a medium-sized agency, the impact is still significant but more manageable. There’s usually a broader team to absorb the responsibilities, though losing a highly skilled or well-connected counselor might still leave a noticeable gap. Medium-sized agencies often benefit from having middle management or specialized roles that can help distribute the burden during transitions.
Large agencies typically have more robust systems and resources to handle departures. However, the stakes can still be high if the departing counselor held a key leadership position or managed significant relationships. For these agencies, maintaining a strong brand and clear operational structures ensures continuity, even during staff turnover.
Understanding when and why departures hurt the most helps you plan ahead, ensuring your agency remains resilient at every stage of growth.
Here’s a radical idea: what if, instead of fearing that counselors might start their own agency, you embraced it? No, really. Think about it. Could you create a model where counselors can grow within your agency without needing to leave?
Instead of losing entrepreneurial counselors to the competition, give them room to innovate within your agency. Maybe they could lead new initiatives, develop specialized programs, or even manage their own team. By empowering them to think like entrepreneurs within your business, you can retain their talent while fostering innovation.
Not every counselor who leaves will become a competitor. Some might become valuable allies, referring students your way or collaborating on projects. Treating them with respect during their departure increases the likelihood of a positive ongoing relationship.
Let’s not sugarcoat it: the possibility of counselors leaving to start their own agency can feel daunting. But here’s the flip side—a little fear keeps you sharp. It pushes you to innovate, nurture your team, and continually improve your business.
Instead of viewing this fear as a threat, see it as an opportunity. An opportunity to build a culture that inspires loyalty, to strengthen your systems and brand, and to foster relationships that endure beyond individual departures. Because at the end of the day, your agency’s success isn’t just about retaining talent—it’s about creating an environment where everyone, counselors included, thrives.
The faster, smoother way to manage payments, for you, your students, and your partners.
